Showing posts with label PPI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PPI. Show all posts

Wednesday, 6 April 2016

When will the Cooling Measures be Removed?

Recently there have been many calls to remove or tweak the cooling measures. But the Government has also repeatedly said it will stay for now and they have a rough idea when to remove it.

The question on everyone's mind is when.

Let me try to second guess that.

According to official numbers from the Urban Redevelopment Authority, property prices have risen some 62% from the trough in 2Q 2009 to the peak in 3Q 2013. In pure numbers, it means if property price on a per sq ft basis is $1,000 in 2009, it would have risen to $1,620 psf in 2013.

 
Source: URA

How much has property prices fallen based on the official price index? Around 9.1% as per the flash estimate for 1Q 2016. It means prices now are around $1,472 psf. Compared to the trough in 2Q 2009, prices are still 47% higher.

This also means property prices have appreciated on average 8% per year from 2009 to 2015. Have our economy grew on average 8% per year over the same period? The answer is no. So property prices have ran ahead of the economy.

So that is probably why the Government is not doing anything.

My guess is a comfortable range in the mind of the Government will be between 15 and 20% fall from the peak. If prices did indeed fall by this amount, the average price appreciation per annum is between 4 and 5%. This price appreciation is closer than economic growth.



15% from Peak
20% from Peak
Estimated Property Prices at end 2016
$1,377 psf
$1,296 psf
Average Price Appreciation per annum
5.4%
4.2%

Source: Real Property Advisory Singapore

When will that happen? Again my guess is by the end of 2016 because 2016 will see the largest number of unit completed.





Thursday, 30 January 2014

Are Private Property Prices Really Falling This Time?

The URA Private Property Price Index (PPI) registered a decline in the last quarter of 2013. Analysts are saying again that prices are starting to ease. They said that in 2012 Q1 when the PPI eased 0.1%. But the PPI rose in 2012 Q2, confounding many.

So is the fall in PPI for real this time?

My take is YES.

Let's take a look at the table below. In 2008 Q3, flash estimates showed a 1.8% decline in PPI. This accelerated to -2.4% when the actual figures were released one month later. This increased expectations that prices will fall further which was proven in 2008 Q4.

In 2012 Q1, the flash estimates and actual figures were the same. What happened in 2012 Q2? The PPI rose instead of falling further.

This time in 2013 Q4, the actual PPI fell more than the flash estimates. This has raised expectations that prices will continue to ease in 2014 which I also believe so.

Period
Flash Estimate
Actual
2008 Q3
-1.8%
-2.4%
2008 Q4
-5.7%
-6.1%
2012 Q1
-0.1%
-0.1%
2012 Q2
0.4%
0.4%
2013 Q4
-0.8%
-0.9%
Source: URA, Real Property Advisory

The key point to note is if the actual figures were higher/lower than flash estimates, the chances of the PPI continuing in the same direction is higher. ie. if the actual figure is lower than flash estimates, the next quarter is likely to be lower.

In 2014 Q1, we have already seen property launches at prices equal or even lower than comparable projects in the same area. Even land bids for executive condominium sites are tempered. This means that developers are managing their costs in case property prices fall further.

Whatever it is, we will know how property prices fare in two months time.