Even though the Total Debt Service Ratio (TDSR) and lowered Loan to Value (LTV) ratio have been implemented for more than a year, I believe the full impact of the measures have yet to surface.
Why?
From the run up in the property market from 2009 to 2013, in the absence of the two measures mentioned above, investors can over-leverage and buy multiple properties. Furthermore banks were dangling attractive interest rates to borrowers with typical lock-in periods of two and three years.
Those who were lucky to refinance before the measures can breathe easy for a while. For those who committed to a purchase from 2011, they will have to grapple with refinancing, easing rentals and the Seller's Stamp Duty (SSD) when the lock-in period ends and the development achieves its temporary occupation permit (TOP).
Borrowers with multiple loans will encounter difficulty refinancing with another bank as they have to meet the TDSR and LTV ratio. Even if they want to sell, they will need to pay SSD. If they hold, they might not be able to rent out the property at their desired rent (if they can find a tenant) to pay the mortgage. Effectively these people are at the mercy of the banks who can increase the interest rates.
Which brings me back to the title of the post - retirees. I know of retirees who depend on their property investments and other investments for passive income. The passive income may not be viewed favourably by banks and can be subjected to hairline cuts when re-assessing the repayment ability in the wake of the two measures. Some retirees might be forced to sell because they either cannot refinance or they face higher mortgage payments exceeding the rental collected on their property(ies).
One retiree is trying to offload his property at 20% below the last transacted price. The measures can deprive them of passive income in their golden years. Can they ever get back into the property market? Unlikely unless they do not take a loan as I do not see the two measures removed because they encourage financial prudence.
There will be more fire-sales coming up whether by retirees or speculators. Already I see owners trying to sell their completed properties of less than ten years for less than $1,000 psf. And these are in the city fringe areas.
Many investors are raring to go but held back because of the additional buyer's stamp duty (ABSD). When this tax is removed, transaction activity in the market is going to spike.
Bringing independent, affordable property advisory services to everyone! Our Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/realpropertyadvisory
Showing posts with label TDSR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label TDSR. Show all posts
Monday, 15 December 2014
Friday, 25 October 2013
Supply, More Supply, Surprised?
The Government just released the statistics on the property market today. The numbers confirmed what analysts have been saying since June 2013 when a tighter TDSR was imposed.
I am not going to harp on that issue. Let the newspapers tomorrow report on that.
Minister Khaw posted an interesting statistic (see picture below). He did not elaborate since the numbers are self explanatory.
Laymen who read the picture below will think that 2016 will see the most number of homes completed. Unfortunately that might not be the true picture.
Let me shed some light.
For every development, we know there is a estimated completion date ie. when the developer must complete the project and apply for temporary occupation permit (TOP). There is also a date for statutory completion. Do you ever wonder how the developer set those dates?
If the developer buys the land parcels from the Government to build executive condominiums (ECs) or private housing, there is a stipulated project completion period. This is the latest date the developer must complete the project and gets the TOP otherwise the Government will take back the land.
- Private property prices continued to appreciate albeit at a slower rate because developers adjusted their price expectations after the tighter TDSR rules kicked in.
- HDB resale flat prices have started to ease as a result of HDB easing more rules to allow people to buy direct from HDB.
I am not going to harp on that issue. Let the newspapers tomorrow report on that.
Minister Khaw posted an interesting statistic (see picture below). He did not elaborate since the numbers are self explanatory.
Laymen who read the picture below will think that 2016 will see the most number of homes completed. Unfortunately that might not be the true picture.
Let me shed some light.
For every development, we know there is a estimated completion date ie. when the developer must complete the project and apply for temporary occupation permit (TOP). There is also a date for statutory completion. Do you ever wonder how the developer set those dates?
If the developer buys the land parcels from the Government to build executive condominiums (ECs) or private housing, there is a stipulated project completion period. This is the latest date the developer must complete the project and gets the TOP otherwise the Government will take back the land.
- For private housing, the project completion period is 60 months or five years from the date of acceptance of the tender bid by the Government
- For ECs, it is 48 months or four years
Then the developer has to obtain the certificate of statutory completion (CSC) within three years. This three years period is set by the Government too.
How about HDB flats you may ask?
HDB operates differently from the private sector. HDB will give you an estimated completion date and an estimated delivery possession date which is something like one year after the estimated completion date. The delivery possession date is the latest HDB must hand over the unit to the buyer.
If the HDB flats are under the Design, Build and Sell Scheme (DBSS), the flats will be completed much earlier than the estimated completion date as it is being built by private developers. Just look at Trivelis and the BTO project beside it. The time difference between the launch of these two projects is a few months. Yet Trivelis is already 50-60% completed while the BTO has just started foundation works.
So the numbers below are based on TOP dates for ECs and private housing and estimated completion date for HDB flats. How accurate are these dates? Not very.
As this is the latest latest date the developer must complete the project, you can bet your last penny that the project will be completed much earlier than that. Whereas for HDB flats, there can be delay up to one year. If it is DBSS, it will be completed earlier.
A rough estimation is that around 20-30% of projects will be earlier than expected. So the peak in completion is likely to be in 2015 instead.
So those who have committed to a property must be prepared to take possession early. For HDB upgraders, be prepared to sell your HDB flat if you need to. As it is now, resale HDB flat prices are moderating. Coupled with mortgage interest rates that is estimated to creep up in late 2014 (if the US Federal Reserve starts to taper its Quantitative Easing), HDB upgraders must brace themselves for higher mortgage repayments by then.
![]() |
| Source: MND |
Friday, 28 June 2013
New Cooling Measure on the Property Market
Although
that the new Total Debt Servicing Ratio (TDSR) have been done and dusted and
even well covered by the media, we feel that the analysis in the media have
missed out certain pertinent points even to the extent of dismissing the new
measure as mild. Some analysts even say it is not a cooling measure. How
can we say it is not a cooling measure when it will affect demand?
- As an analyst, I have brought up the issue of financial institutions granting loans where the debt servicing ratio (DSR) was as high as 60% and different financial institutions have different ways of assessing the ability of borrowers to repay the loan to the media.
- The Monetary Authority of Singapore imposed a mortgage servicing ratio (similar to DSR) of 30%/35% on the HDB market on 12 January 2013. It is a matter of time this is extended to the private residential market.
- This measure has bite in our opinion. The TDSR takes into account all the outstanding debts a borrower has. These debts can include car loans, credit card installments, study loans and all kinds of debts the borrower is repaying at the moment.
- Unlike previous cooling measures where the Government has hinted that it will be temporary, Minister Khaw has said that this measure will be permanent because the financial institutions did not have a structured way of assessing the ability of borrowers to repay loans. And the ratio can be lowered too!
- The interest rate used to compute TDSR is not the current low rate of 1% but the medium term rate of 3.5% for housing loans. This means to comply with the TDSR of 60%, the borrower has to cough up more cash, borrowing less from the financial institutions.
- Guarantors have to be the co-owner of the property. This effectively closes the loophole where cash rich parents used their child’s name to buy a property to qualify for a 80% loan and avoid paying the Additional Buyer’s Stamp Duty.
- Demand will come down for sure be it near term or long term.
- Interest rate will go up. Why? Imagine a financial institution has $1 million to lend. When the borrower can borrow up to 80%, the bank need only to find one or two borrowers to take up the $1 million. The tighter loan to value ratio implemented previously means the financial institution means the financial institution has to source for two to three borrowers to take up the $1 million. Now with the TDSR, the financial institution needs more than three borrowers to take up the $1 million. But the number of borrowers will decline with the new TDSR as well. This means to maintain the profit margin (which is already razor thin now), interest rates have to go up.
- Developers will build smaller units to keep them affordable to buyers. Currently the average unit size in new launches is around 81 sq m in the first six months of 2013. This is expected to go down to 70 sq m which is the minimum set by the Urban Redevelopment Authority.
- Resale market will see dip in demand as their unit sizes are bigger than the new launches.
What will
be the impact on the property market?
The
Government still has a few more tricks up their sleeves. If I may guess, they
might require buyers to have the full cash in their bank account before they
can buy from new launches. Some buyers do not have 50% cash in their banks when
they take a second property loan. They may have 40% cash and because payment to
the developer is on a progressive mode, the remaining 10% will be saved up over
a period of one to two years.
The thing
to note is this measure is not the last and it will stay even if the market
corrects!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
